Pricing

Decorated Cookie Flavors – Sugar, Red Velvet and Cinnamon Citrus

Cookies:

  • Basic Custom Decorated Cookies
    $60 a dozen-same cookie/same flavor

  • Cookie Kits For All Occasions
    $30-10 cookies, 3 bags of icing and 2 bags of sprinkles

Cookie Dough
***2 weeks notice required for all cookie dough and cookie dough kits

  • $60 Cookie Dough Kits for Every Season

    3 flavors available/ Sugar, Red Velvet and Cinnamon Citrus
    - Kits include 4 pound of cookie dough, 3 large bags of yummy frosting and 2 cookie cutters. This kit is offered while supplies last. Enjoy a day of baking made easy with your family or give a sweet gift to someone special!

  • $40 Cookie Dough

Lunch Box Cookies

  • $30-Surprise your child with a special note written on something sweet!

    15 cookies with an edible pen. Cookies come in bright primary colors and individually packaged. You may freeze these cookies up to 3 months in an airtight container or in a large zip lock bag for optimum freshness. Simply remove a cookie (or two) from the freezer, write your child a special note and pop in their lunch box! 

    When I was a little girl, my mom would leave a special note with a sweet treat in my lunch box. When I became a mom, I did the same. The Costa Cookie Company decided to combine the two ideas into one, A sweet treat you can write on!

Cupcakes

  • $3.75 simply designs/sold by the dozen-same

  • $4.00 and up for detailed designs

Cakes

***All of our cakes are custom made per order/prices to be discussed

  • Fondant Cakes

  • Naked Cakes

  • Buttercream and Drip Cakes

Birthday Brownie

  • $55
    10” round chocolate chip fudge brownie, covered in a coat of homemade buttercream frosting, decorated w/ chocolate covered potato chips, M&M’s, gummy life savers, rainbow sweet and sour squares, topped w/ shaved white chocolate.
    ***Please give us a minimum of 2 weeks notice prior to creating your birthday brownie!

Cinnamon Rolls

  • $36/ dozen-Hartland pick up only, limited quantities available!

Donuts – Our Donuts are baked (not fried) with a sweet cake like interior!

  • $15/4 Chocolate Chip Donut - Double Deckers

  • $20/12 Chocolate Covered Bacon Donut - Single

Candy Boxes For Every Season

  • $35/box
    Our candy boxes contain chocolate covered popcorn, our famous peanut butter balls, homemade caramel and chocolate bark. Our chocolate bark flavors change with every season!

Turtles

  • $20/5 pieces
    Our turtles are made with our homemade caramel, chocolate sauce and the freshest pecans! Our turtles are made fresh daily.

Candy Kabobs – A fun, sweet and unique treat!

  • $10/each

S’more Kits

  • $7/ per kit
    Kits include 2 graham crackers, one printed marshmallow and one Hershey Chocolate bar

Chocolate Covered Pretzels For Any Occasion!

  • $4/each for chocolate covered pretzels

  • $5/each for chocolate and candy covered pretzels

  • $6/each for Turtle Pretzels

Enjoy a bag of our homemade caramels

  • Our caramels are rich and creamy, made with the very best ingredients. Made fresh daily!

  • 7.5oz (12 pieces) / $15.50

Trilby Cookies

  • $36/dozen

  • This is an Oatmeal sandwich cookie with a sweet date filling

***Full payment is required at the time an order is placed
Payment methods: Cash, Check, Venmo or Credit Card - Please note all credit cards are subject to a 3% fee

Our Gift Certificates

Our gift certificates can be used to purchase cookies, any products we have along with our cookie classes.


Price options in increments:

  • $25

  • $50

  • $75

  • $100

PLEASE NOTE: Cookies are NOT made in a nut free kitchen and products may contain or come in contact with milk, wheat, gluten, nuts, cocoa and/or other products that may result in allergic or other reactions. It is the responsibility of the Customer and/or cake/cookie recipient to be aware of allergy issues and to inform him/her of this fact. Baker does not guarantee any cake/cookie or other products to be allergen free and is not responsible for any allergic reactions referred to above for those that are susceptible to these products.